Why Your Eye Retouching Looks Fake (And the Layered Workflow That Fixes It)
Every few months I get a new student in my workshop who shows me their eye retouching and asks why it looks “off.” The whites are too white. The iris looks painted. The catchlights are perfect little circles that no real light source ever made. They’ve done everything right, technically, and the result is completely unconvincing. I know that feeling intimately. Early in my retouching career, a client looked at a portrait I’d delivered and said, without any malice, “she looks like a doll.